Internet Goosing the Antithesis

Thursday, October 12, 2006

The Christian Marriage Problem

You may recall last year that I mentioned Craig Sowder's (formerly of the "Through the Eyes of Faith" blog, now renamed as "Autonomy is Madness") observation that Christian women are crazy. I have a lot of sympathy for Craig's perspective, and in a lot of ways I see his path in life as one that I could easily have taken, were it not for some hard questions I asked myself. Craig is, in all practical senses, a great guy, working hard at the insurance industry, trying to make a life for himself in the big city of Chicago, away from his friends and family in Southern Kentucky. That kind of life can be lonely- my brother-in-law lived in Chicago for a year before moving back to be closer to his family. And it's especially hard when you're a single guy, trying to follow your religious convictions. Almost as hard, I would guess, as being a single atheist.

Which is why reading this article posted to Blog and Mablog really rubbed Craig the wrong way. It's a reference to a book that criticizes Christian singles, especially men, for not getting married by the age of 28. Getting close to that age himself, and without a matrimonial prospect, Craig spouted off at length about his criticism of such an idea.

Now, Craig makes it clear that he's shooting from the hip here, which I appreciate. Common sense is usually aligned with the correct moral interpretation, and it's only in overthinking things that we run the risk of allowing ourselves to be rationalized into a conclusion that doesn't work.

The criticism aimed at single Christians is thus: marriage is part of God's plan, so if you're not getting married, you're trying to thwart God. Craig's rebuttal is: Hey! Relationships are hard, especially in this day and age, and even more especially with Christian women, so get off my back!

I can really sympathize with Craig- relationships are hard (and by the way, they don't get any easier once you're married), and it's especially hard to make a meaningful relationship with a Christian woman. In fact, just this past weekend I had a visit from an old friend, and we sat around drinking beer and reminiscing about the people we grew up with. The town I went to high school in was pleasantly rural, and circumstances had caused it to be populated by an inordinately high percentage of Christians. There was, literally, only one atheist in the school that I knew of, but the domination by Christians and Christian mindsets was just so overwhelming that it was barely noticed. Suffice it to say, all the girls that were in my class were Christian, and dating was quite a chore. As we ran through the list in our recollection, my friend and I had a lot of trouble picking out a single girl from our class who didn't end up having severe psychological problems, become pathologically promiscuous, or suddenly married a much older man (or all three). We were inclined to think that perhaps there was just something odd in the water in our hometown, but reading Craig's characterization strongly suggests that there might be a theological reason for this instead.

Marriage is a special relationship between two people who find in each other the fulfillment of their core values. But for Christians, marriage IS the value- and fulfilling it is the end of the story. It doesn't really matter so much who the person is- just that it's a good Christian who wants kids. As Craig quotes from Doug Wilson, "Find out who she is, and marry her." It's precisely this casual attitude levied toward men who have reached their late twenties without getting hitched that is the problem. Is it really such a big suprise that divorce is most prevalent among Christian couples, if the only concern is finding "someone" instead of the "right one?" Craig rightly points out that finding a wife is not like picking out a jar of jelly in the grocery store. In the best case scenario, you might be able to pick out a woman who values marriage so much that she's willing to put up with an unfulfilling relationship if it means following God's will for her life.

But then you end up with another problem- in the Christian marriage paradigm, both people are supposed to value their relationship with God more than their relationship with the other person. This serves an obvious memetic purpose- if both spouses are committed Christians, they will tend to pass on their religious understanding to any children they may have. But this is also a dangerous loophole- since her husband is outranked by God, then any Christian woman could conceivably justify any imaginable action on her part, up to and including infidelity and divorce, simply by rationalizing it as "God's will for her life." The progressive liberalization of Western culture has, in fact, served to erode the tight grip that husbands once held over their wives- men are supposed to be the "spiritual leaders" of the marriage, after all- and Christian women are feeling more and more empowered to think for themselves, and more importantly, to come to their own decisions about what "God wants" in their lives.

Now, don't get me wrong- what I think is bad for Christian marriage is good for secular marriage. I mean, according to the Bible, Christian marriage isn't worth all that much anyway. What I find so unfortunate is that so many women are treating men badly, good men like Craig Sowder who, Christian or not, are also looking for someone to love and be loved by in return. The only solution, as I see it, is to promote a secular approach to marriage, as I mentioned before- leave God out of it.

(And, as it happens, I am ordained as a minister and am able to officiate any secular ceremony if needed, free of charge.)

Post a Comment


At 10/12/2006 5:34 PM, Blogger Aaron Kinney declaimed...

BWAHAHAHA! Is autonomy madness, or is it the opposite, huh?

Good post Zach. I just HAD to write about this too, since Ive been writing a bunch of posts lately about the evils of treating women like property instead of "autonomous" humans:

At 10/12/2006 11:26 PM, Blogger Dan Doel declaimed...

If marriage is part of god's plan, can't he wiggle his nose and hook this guy up with a nice wife? How could he even hope to thwart god's plan by not getting married? Isn't it far more likely that god's plan is that this guy not be married yet, since, you know, god is omnipotent, and everything happens according to his will?

I guess it's good to know that many Christians feel free to annoy even each other with their illogic.

At 10/13/2006 9:39 AM, Blogger Joe Otten declaimed...

Ah its much too hard on Christian guys. They don't have to marry. Best of all, they can become eunuchs.

[Matthew 19:12 For there are some eunuchs, which were so born from their mother's womb: and there are some eunuchs, which were made eunuchs of men: and there be eunuchs, which have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake. He that is able to receive it, let him receive it.]

At 10/13/2006 12:55 PM, Blogger TV's Mr. Neil declaimed...

I really like how the Bible characterizes becoming a eunuch as "receiving" something.

God is so good.

At 10/13/2006 4:01 PM, Blogger Aaron Kinney declaimed...

Receiving != getting balls chopped off.

LOL maybe we should be championing MAtt 19:12 to Christians more often, eh?

At 1/28/2007 1:13 PM, Blogger ncf declaimed...

I enjoyed this post and linked to it (hope you don't mind). Thank you for saying what only a few of us are willing to say about the female-dominated churches.

At 11/26/2007 10:04 PM, Blogger Lauressa declaimed...

No matter what books are written
like Deb Maken's

Marriage is NOT for everyone.
A marriage of two commited people can be a joy and a gift from God;

Sure it IS lonely to be single in a big city when your friends are hooked up dating or even married.

I remember those days.

You men on this site might listen to John Townsend and Henry Cloud on New Life Ministries to get a better handle on healthy Christian women.

T and C are plugged into the world and helping alot of men and women of all ages.
Happy New Year Laressa

At 12/27/2007 6:03 AM, Blogger blog49 declaimed...

This blog is really fantastic as I have gone through all the posts. I don't know why the blog mater is not interested in posting some more relative information. I request the blog mater to add some more content to this great blog. I shall link from my blogs to this blog soon.
I have come across a nice matrimonial site where you have no pay nothing for registration of your profiles and also for searching for apt profiles. This is an entire free service for every one at this moment. Please logon to and register your profile for free.
Later come and search for suitable profiles. We are going to promote this new service heavily so millions will login to the site all will see your profile free. So act now and visit the site to register now.

At 10/01/2008 11:08 AM, Blogger Heather declaimed...

Ok, I had to make a comment because both of you are very biased when it comes to a " good, christian marriage." I myself am a christian woman married to a christian man, and we love each other very much. He is my right one and I am his. I wasn't so desperate that I would marry anyone and neither was he.

Relationships are hard, and marriage is 10 times harder. So, you need Christ in your life to help you make healthy and wise decisions in your marriage. I gladly submit to my husband as well as I am his equal as he listens to my input. That is a real "christian marriage".

A true woman of God knows this, and is not crazy at all. You just have to be on her level to understand her thoughts. I admit that there are those that tag themselves Christian as if it is a club, but really have no relationship with Christ at all. Those are the ones of which you speak of in your blog, and they are the ones that even I can not befriend.

No... everyone is not made to be married, as so stated in the word of God. However, God created marriage to be a union of love, trust, and commitment between man and woman, as it is so with Christ and the church. And between the right man and woman, the union is wonderfully blessed. So, stop being so one-sided. Perhaps the real problem is you want your cake and ice cream before you present the ring. Get it together guys!!

At 11/28/2009 5:07 AM, Blogger Adi declaimed...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa


<< Home